View all posts

Has Facebook Made Us All Narcissists?

facebook narcissismYou are more than likely one of the 1.19 billion monthly active Facebook users.

Perhaps you have seen how others –and possibly yourself– have become infatuated with posting updates and photos of every moment of their life on the site. Has Facebook affected our self-image? Are we narcissistic?

A 2010 study at York University found that self-promotion on Facebook correlates with self-esteem in college students.

Your college years typically include some self-defining moments. The friends, the parties, the wonderful exams and projects *sarcasm*. With the rampant use of Facebook in this impressionable demographic, one’s self-perception can easily be influenced.

To find the extent of Facebook’s influence on college students, a group of social scientists at Penn State University conducted an examination that was one of the first of its kind: how Facebook usage is related to the psychological aspects of students’ lives. We’ve broken down the study into four easy-to-follow sections: Method, Measures, Results, and Implications. And we left plenty of room for your thoughts, too!

Method

Students attending the not unambiguous “non-residential college near a large metropolitan area in the northeastern United States” (your guess is as good as mine) were invited to participate in the study and received enough money to purchase 200 packets of Ramen noodles. The hypotheses looked to link time and emotional investment with the user’s self-image.

Measures

Attitudes and behaviors towards Facebook and body image were measured using two scales: the Facebook Intensity scale and the Multidimensional Body-Self Relations Questionnaire. It was quite fitting to use scales on a body image study. The variables for Facebook included number of friends, daily time spent, and attitude toward the social network. Appearance orientation and evaluation were the two body image variables.

Results

There is enough meat in this study to feed a small army, as the results section goes on for a few pages, but we’ll serve you the finest slice. So, here’s your filet mignon: Individuals who were more emotionally invested in Facebook and spent less time on the network were more concerned with their appearance.

Facebook and Body Image

If you have an appetite for a statistics table, consider it satisfied.

Implications

facebook narcissismIn a society that emphasizes the unrealistic ideals of thinness and sexiness for women and muscularity for men, college students are influenced to fit the ideal.  As a very visual medium, Facebook allows users to carefully construct an image of themselves, although that virtual image may not resemble reality.

Therefore, the bridge between social capital and self-esteem is unsteady. Time spent on the site may not matter because the user’s concerns with looks will affect their behavior towards the network. Some of those concerned with their looks may limit their time on Facebook to protect their self-image while others may visit the site frequently to seek social comparisons.

What Do You Think?

Have you seen some examples of Facebook’s influence on body image?

What measures would you recommend to reduce its influence?

What are some other implications from this research?

You can type your comment below or use the SpeakPipe widget on the side of the page to leave a voicemail.

  • Pingback: Is Social Media Powering Our Own Narcissism? | Conversational Marketing Blog | Social Media Community Managers | Call Center Management | Incept Results

  • Jay

    If you were heavily invested in the network, wouldn’t you spend more time on it?

    • http://carsonreider.weebly.com Carson Reider

      Jay,

      Thanks for asking! First, a quick explanation: “emotional investment” here refers to how individuals feel about Facebook as a social networking site. For example, one who searches “delete Facebook” on Google could be said to have a negative view of the social network.

      To answer your question, it could seem to go hand in hand. If a person likes Facebook, spending more time on the site makes theoretical sense. However, it is not always true.

      One may not like the network, but may frequently visit it for social comparison with peers.

    • http://nateriggs.com/ nateriggs

      Guess I don’t understand the point you are making, Jay. Can you explain?

      • Lee

        I think the point is that even if you don’t like social media you may feel ‘compelled’ to login and compare yourself with others… I may be wrong though.

    • http://carsonreider.weebly.com/ Carson Reider

      Jay,

      Thanks for asking! First, a quick explanation: “emotional investment”
      here refers to how individuals feel about Facebook as a social
      networking site. For example, one who searches “delete Facebook” on
      Google could be said to have a negative view of the social network.

      To answer your question, it could seem to go hand in hand. If a
      person likes Facebook, spending more time on the site makes theoretical
      sense. However, it is not always true.

      One may not like the network, but may frequently visit it for social comparison with peers.

  • Pingback: What Are the Seven Social Media Building Blocks?

  • Pingback: Facebook's Emotional Contagion? About That...